Glossier Inner Circle: a 10-email mobile series
Service:
Email marketing
Ten emails, every one under 175 words, that answer a brand's broken trust with binding customer votes instead of an apology.
Download: PDF
Speculative portfolio work. Not commissioned by or affiliated with Glossier Inc. All concepts, names and figures (Inner Circle, Trust Loop System, survey counts, budgets) are fictional.
Have a brief like this? Book a 30-minute call or email it.
The copy
Email 1: Past Tense
Sarah,
Not "I am." Past tense. Used to be.
You can pinpoint the moment. Maybe when you opened new Balm Dotcom and it felt wrong. Or when you saw the Sephora announcement and felt grief, not excitement.
You're mourning an identity.
Being a "Glossier girl" meant something. Natural over full-coverage. Community over celebrity. You weren't just buying makeup—you were part of a movement.
Then we became what we disrupted.
The betrayal wasn't that we changed. It's that you had no say.
You went from partner to passenger. Watching changes happen TO you instead of WITH you.
We built Boy Brow because you asked for it. Cloud Paint launched because you requested it. The co-creation was real.
Until it wasn't.
Tomorrow: What's different now.
— The Glossier Team
P.S. We stopped asking. We started deciding. That's the betrayal.
173 words
Email 2: The Trust Loop System™
Sarah,
Before we launch, reformulate, or discontinue anything else, you'll see it first.
Not after the fact. Not a PR statement.
You'll approve it. Or you won't. Your vote will be binding.
The Trust Loop System™:
We propose (before budget allocation)
You test (30 days, real life)
You vote (Launch/Don't Launch/Fix First)
We respond (public dashboard shows decision)
Re-test (if needed, until 85%+ approval)
Launch (only if you approve)
Your power moved from END to BEGINNING.
I know you're thinking: "I've heard 'we're listening' from every brand that screwed up."
Fair. Words are cheap.
Tomorrow: Meet Rachel, who tested this system and changed a product launch.
— The Glossier Team
P.S. This isn't feedback. It's governance. Big difference.
139 words
Email 3: Rachel's Story
Sarah,
Meet Rachel.
Long-time customer. Done with us after the reformulation.She joined Inner Circle beta to tell us everything we did wrong.
First test: Reformulated Milky Jelly Cleanser.
Her feedback: "Headache within 30 seconds. Smells synthetic, not fresh like the original. Can't use this."
She expected us to ignore it.
Two weeks later:
"Rachel - 44 testers flagged headache/synthetic scent. You're right. We're adjusting the fragrance. New version ships in 3 weeks."She re-tested. She voted YES.
Product launched. Her name appears on the product page: "Approved by Rachel M. and 2,847 Inner Circle members."
Rachel's take: "I don't fully trust Glossier again. But I trust the PROCESS."
That's binding votes in action.
Tomorrow: Design the governance structure that prevents future betrayals.
VERIFY IN DASHBOARD →
— The Glossier Team
147 words
Email 4: Write The Rules
Sarah,
Take this 2-minute survey.
You're not giving feedback. You're writing the rules we'll follow.
Questions:
What approval % for reformulations? (70%? 85%?)
What happens if we bypass votes?
How much advance notice do you need?
Who gets veto power?
If you say "I need veto power on reformulations," we're writing it into our Terms of Service. Legally binding.
This is your chance to determine how much power you have.
Not how much we give you. How much you demand.
3,000 spots available. First come, first served.
TAKE SURVEY - CLAIM YOUR SPOT
Tomorrow: We'll show what you told us + the governance structure you built.
— The Glossier Team
P.S. Survey is anonymous. Tell us everything we did wrong. We need that more than nice comments.
144 words
Email 5: You Set The Terms
Sarah,
3,124 of you took the survey in 72 hours.
We had 3,000 spots. We're expanding to 3,500.What you demanded:
85% approval threshold for any changes
Automatic refunds if we bypass votes
Public apology within 48 hours
Products pulled immediately
All four are now in our Terms of Service. Section 4.2. Legally binding.
WHAT YOU GET:
Binding votes on all launches/reformulations
15% off everything, forever
Your name on products you approve
Dashboard verification of everything
Legal protections if we violate terms
The Dashboard is live. Everything we claim? You can verify.
JOIN INNER CIRCLE
Tomorrow: Vote on our next launch—even if you're not a member yet.
— The Glossier Team
P.S. You built us once. Now let's rebuild—together, for real.
140 words
Email 6: Your Vote, Our Budget
Sarah,
Three products ready. One launches June. You decide which.
OPTION A: Non-Sticky Lip Gloss
Fix stickiness (67% complain) but might reduce wear 10-15%OPTION B: Cloud Paint "Brick"
Warm brick red (3,124 requests). First version pulled orange. Fixed now.OPTION C: Body Hero Original
2018 formula return. Not vegan. Can't sell EU. Running both versions.Your vote is binding. Monday morning, $120K gets allocated to winner.
Current tally:
Cloud Paint: 41% (1,441 votes)
Lip Gloss: 34% (1,197 votes)
Body Hero: 25% (879 votes)
VOTE NOW - 47 HOURS LEFT
You can vote even if not a member. Preview of your power.
Tomorrow: Results + what happens to the losers.
— The Glossier Team
139 words
Email 7: We Killed $225K Worth
Sarah,
Cloud Paint "Brick" won. 43%.
$120K allocated Monday. Verify in dashboard.But here's what else your votes did:
Last 6 months, Inner Circle killed 3 launches:
Stretch Concealer Expansion: 73% yes. Killed anyway. Why? The 27% said "Fix oxidizing first." Cost: $75K
Lidstar Reformulation: 36% yes. Killed. "Texture wrong." Cost: $100K
Cloud Paint "Terracotta": 36% yes. Killed. "Too orange." Cost: $50K
Total: $225,000 spent on products that will never launch.
If we'd launched anyway: $800K+ in returns and lost trust.
Your votes saved us $575K.
This is what "for real" costs: $225,000.
SEE KILLED PRODUCTS IN DASHBOARD →
Tomorrow: The truth about Sephora.
— The Glossier Team
134 words
Email 8: The Sephora Truth
Sarah,
You were right about Sephora.
You said: "This will change everything. Glossier won't be special anymore."
We said you were being dramatic.
We were wrong.
What you lost:
The insider feeling
Pink bubble wrap ritual
"Glossier girl" identity
These losses were real.
But the special thing wasn't WHERE you shopped. It was HOW MUCH POWER YOU HAD in shaping what we made.
The new exclusive:
Anyone can buy Glossier at Sephora.
Only 3,500 people can GOVERN Glossier.You're not deciding what to buy. You're deciding what 40,000 Sephora shoppers will be able to buy in 6 months.
"I'm Inner Circle" > "I'm a Glossier girl"
Tomorrow: Final invitation.
— The Glossier Team
130 words
Email 9: 396 Spots Left
Sarah,
The timeline:
11 days ago: You were a former Glossier girl
Day 3: Your survey shaped our Terms
Day 6: Your vote decided our next launch
Day 7: You saw the $225K we killed
Now: 3,104 of 3,500 spots claimed. 396 remaining.
Wednesday midnight: Enrollment closes.
If you join:
Permanent governance rights
Beta test Cloud Paint (March)
15% off forever
Your name on products
If you wait:
Watch others govern
Buy at full price
Find out at launch like everyone
You built Boy Brow with a comment. Cloud Paint with a request.
Now rebuild everything—with binding, legal power.
JOIN INNER CIRCLE - 396 SPOTS
47 hours left.
— The Glossier Team
130 words
Email 10: Your Seat At The Table
Sarah,
You built us once.
Boy Brow exists because you asked. Cloud Paint launched because you requested. That was real co-creation.
Until we forgot.
Now we're asking: Do you want your power back?
Not the power to comment and hope. The power to vote and know it's binding.
Not promises. Terms of Service that make your votes legally protected.
Not "Glossier girl" identity. "Inner Circle member" governance.
THREE WAYS TO RESPOND:
[JOIN INNER CIRCLE]
396 spots left. Get voting rights + 15% off forever.[KEEP ME UPDATED]
Watch from sidelines. No votes or discounts.[UNSUBSCRIBE]
You've moved on. We get it.The choice is yours. The deadline is tonight.
— The Glossier Team
P.S. If this is BS, Section 4.2 triggers automatic refunds. You're protected.
140 words
TOTAL WORD COUNT: 1,409 words
Average per email: 141 words
All emails under 175-word limit ✓
The mockup
Hi, I'm Ezekiel
I partner with B2B SaaS, AI, and Health Tech founders and growth agencies to transform complex technical architecture, raw founder interviews, and strategic briefs into white-label SEO assets, executive newsletters, and conversion lifecycle systems.
- Read the writingBylined articles, the NEST Notes newsletter and two essays on how I write.
- Services and ways to workRetainers, overflow and fixed-scope packages.
- All workEvery piece on the site, filterable by lane.
